Lodge Color Skillet, Island Spice Red, 11"
by Lodge
List Price:
Our Price: $33.99
You Save: $26.01 (43%)
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Category: Kitchen
See more product details
Product Summary
Manufacturer: LodgeBrand: Lodge
Release Date: 2007-07-15
Model: Lodge Color
Color: Island Spice Red
Product features:
- Porcelain surface eliminates the need to season
- Superior heat distribution and retention
- Two layers of porcelain enamel are chip resistant
- Hygienic porcelain enamel is non-reactive with food
- Easy clean up
Kitchen and Housewares Reviews of Lodge Color Skillet, Island Spice Red, 11"
Customer Review: A Bad Example of a Bad Idea
Summary: 1 Stars
This pan gets a star for being kinda pretty and essentially being what it claims to be; an enamel covered, cast-iron pan. It loses two stars for falling short within its category, and two stars for the poor performance of its category, in general.
The Failings of This Specific Pan
The interior of the pan is sort of a rough, micro-textured, abrasive surface. I find that if I wipe it with a cloth or paper towel, it comes away covered in tiny cotton fibers. Not being interested in eating cotton, I have to rinse it again, and let it air dry.
The problem with this is that Lodge's cleaning instructions state, in bold letters, "DO NOT AIR DRY". I e-mailed them asking what exactly the risk in air drying is, and they said the pan may rust, "around the edges". This seems odd, considering that the point of coating the pan is to eliminate this problem. But it turns out this is a hint that Lodge does not expect the enamel coating to last.
Sure enough, within one week of use, I began discovering chips in the enamel of both this pan and a similar Dutch oven by Lodge. And I do mean "discovering". I never dropped either item, and there were no "Bang - Whoops" moments. I just found small patches of enamel missing. This seems mostly to be happening on the bottom of the pan, where it interacts with the cooking surface, but it is not limited to that area.
An enamel coating that won't stay on the pan defeats the purpose of its own existence.
Another problem with this pan is that it is poorly balanced. Its solid iron handle causes it to list to one side on a cooking surface with any give (like most electric coils). It may also have problems sitting flat on many cooking surfaces with significant gaps (like many gas burners).
The General Failings of Cast Iron
It seems that "high end" pans tend to have thick aluminum cores. This is because aluminum "transmits heat" very efficiently. An aluminum core moves heat from the point of contact, throughout the entire pan, causing its cooking surface to be heated relatively evenly (no hot or cold spots), regardless of the location or shape of the heat source. In addition, the mass of a thick core, and the encasing steel, will store heat, so that adding cold food to the heated pan will have reduced effect on its temperature.
It may seem (as it initially did to me) that if a thick aluminum core is good, then a heavy cast iron core should be great. This is not the case. If it were, they wouldn't bother with aluminum cores in pans made of steel (which happens to be iron, infused with carbon). They go to the trouble and cost of sandwiching an aluminum core between layers of steel because it greatly improves the pan's performance.
The only thing Iron's sheer mass has going for it is a thermal stability that minimizes cooling when you add food. Unfortunately, the overkill of Iron's mass also minimizes cooling when you remove it from heat, and minimizes heating when you put it on the burner. And iron doesn't have aluminum's heat transmission properties. It is easy to get hot spots or inadvertently overheat the pan (after a long wait). The result is that, with cast iron, it takes much longer to cook, and it's very easy to burn food. In addition, due to the pan being "cast" as a single piece, it's only a matter of time until the solid iron handle burns your hand (perhaps 10 minutes after you've taken it off the heat).
Iron is very prone to rusting, and despite the reassurances of those who live with it, this, along with its maintenance needs, unwieldy weight, and heat retention, all conspire to greatly complicate the purportedly simple activity of cleaning it.
Despite all this, cast iron pans are still sold because they are relatively cheap, and under the right conditions, they have a sort of non-stick surface.
The General Failings of Enamel Coating
Coating iron pans with enamel theoretically addresses rusting and maintenance issues. Unfortunately, it also defeats both of the reasons that iron is even still being used. The enamel coating costs more than the iron pan itself, and it isn't non-stick.
Conclusion
If, in addition to the general failings of cast iron and enamel coating, you get an oddly textured and flaky coating, and an unbalanced pan, what you have is a pan that:
- takes longer to heat than it takes to cook,
- won't sit flat on the burner,
- heats unevenly, overheats, and promotes food burning,
- takes forever to cool, and will probably burn you at some point,
- can't be washed for 30 minutes after using or it may crack,
- has an oddly rough interior, making it difficult to clean and dry,
- has no non-stick properties,
- is super heavy and unwieldy (a bad combination with scalding, slick enameled handles),
- is too expensive for cast iron,
- will probably end up rusting,
- is just basically a complete disaster.
Bottom line: Don't buy this pan.
Description of Lodge Color Skillet, Island Spice Red, 11"
This 11" enamel skillet is great for cooking on gas, electric, ceramic and induction cooktops, as well as in the oven. Not recommended for use on outdoor grills or over open outdoor flames. Not for use in microwaves. The use of vegetable oil or cooking spray is recommended for better cooking and clean up. Select low to medium heat when cooking on stovetop, and never heat an empty pan. Use of wooden or silicon utensils is recommended. Lodge Color Porcelain Enamel on Cast Iron cookware is cast from molten iron in individual sand molds. The porcelain surface eliminates the need to season cast iron. The cast iron vessel has superior heat distribution and retention, evenly heating bottom sidewalls. The excellent heat retention reduces the amount of energy needed for cooking. Two layers of very hard, glossy porcelain enamel are chip resistant and easy to clean. The black cooking surface on the skillet is matte porcelain, not exposed cast iron. Hygienic porcelain enamel is non-reactive with food. Although dishwasher safe, hand washing with warm soapy water is recommended to preserve the cookware's original appearance. 11" diameter, 1 3/4" deep. Island SpiceAll Pans
Kitchen and Housewares
Most talked about in Lodge
Lodge Logic Pre-Seasoned Rectangular Cast-Iron Grill PressLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2004-03-01; Kitchen
Best price: $13.98
Price in other shops:
Lodge Logic Pre-Seasoned 1-Pint Country KettleLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2004-03-01; Kitchen
Best price: $9.58
Price in other shops:
Lodge Logic L8DOL3 Pre-Seasoned 5-Quart Dutch Oven with Loop HandlesLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2004-03-01; Kitchen
Best price: $30.54
Price in other shops:
Lodge Logic Pre-Seasoned 17-Inch Cast Iron SkilletLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2004-03-01; Kitchen
Best price: $53.54
Price in other shops:
Lodge Logic L14SK3 15-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast-Iron SkilletLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2004-03-01; Kitchen
Best price: $31.09
Price in other shops:
Lodge Camp Dutch Oven TripodLodge; Lodge; Kitchen
Best price: $25.99
Price in other shops:
Lodge Pro-Logic Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron 12-Inch Square Grill PanLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2004-02-05; Kitchen
Best price: $23.34
Price in other shops:
Lodge Pro-Logic Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron 10-Inch Round Grill PanLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2004-02-05; Kitchen
Price in other shops:
Lodge Logic 7-Quart Dutch Oven with Spiral Handle Bail and Iron CoverLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2007-07-15; Kitchen
Best price: $49.99
Price in other shops:
Lodge Logic L10SK3 12-Inch Pre-Seasoned SkilletLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2005-05-01; Kitchen
Best price: $20.95
Price in other shops:
Similar Kitchen and Housewares Products
Lodge Color Skillet, Emerald Green, 11"Lodge Manufacturing Company; Lodge; Release date: 2008-03-25; Kitchen
Best price: $34.99
Price in other shops:
Lodge Color Enamel Cast Iron 8.5 inch Square Panini Press, Island Spice RedLodge; Lodge; Kitchen
Best price: $19.99
Price in other shops:
Lodge Cast Iron Scrubber BrushLodge; Lodge; Lodge; Kitchen; Home
Best price: $3.15
Price in other shops:
Lodge Color Dutch Oven, Island Spice Red, 7.5-QuartLodge Manufacturing Company; Lodge; Release date: 2010-04-01; Kitchen
Best price: $75.38
Price in other shops:
Lodge Color Covered Casserole, Island Spice Red, 3-QuartLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2007-07-15; Kitchen
Best price: $53.87
Price in other shops:
Lodge Color Dutch Oven, Island Spice Red, 3-QuartLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2007-07-15; Kitchen
Best price: $44.89
Price in other shops:
Lodge Color Square Grill Pan, Island Spice Red, 10"Lodge; Lodge; Kitchen
Best price: $53.93
Price in other shops:
Lodge Set of 2 Durable Polycarbonate Pan Scrapers,Red and BlackLodge Manufacturing Company; Lodge; Release date: 2010-04-01; Kitchen
Best price: $2.57
Lodge Max Temp Handle Mitt, BlackLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2004-03-01; Kitchen
Best price: $3.80
Price in other shops:
Lodge Color Dutch Oven, Island Spice Red, 6-QuartLodge; Lodge; Release date: 2007-07-15; Kitchen
Best price: $52.50
Price in other shops: